Choosing a great insurance agent in Bartlett means finding someone who understands both the local landscape and your unique coverage needs—whether it’s protecting your home from Memphis-area storms or finding affordable auto insurance for your work commute. Bartlett residents are lucky to have a strong mix of independent agencies and well-known carriers right in their backyard, and the reviews from neighbors speak volumes. To help you narrow it down, we’ve rounded up the top-rated insurance agents in Bartlett based on real customer feedback.
- Scotty Dunnam - State Farm Insurance Agent — 2838 Stage Center Cove Suite 3, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. With a perfect 5.0-star rating from 380 reviews, Scotty Dunnam is a trusted name along the Stage Road corridor. Customers consistently praise his team for clear explanations and fast claims help, making them a go-to for homeowners and drivers in the Bartlett area.
- Joseph Green - State Farm Insurance Agent — 2830 Summer Oaks Dr Suite 101, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Joseph Green also boasts a flawless 5.0-star rating, though from a smaller sample of 27 reviews. Located near Summer Oaks Drive, this agency is known for its personalized service and willingness to walk new clients through every policy option.
- Farmers Insurance - Charles Skipper — 6520 Stage Rd Ste 101, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Charles Skipper at Farmers Insurance holds a 5.0-star rating from 4 reviews. While the number of reviews is low, the feedback highlights his attentive, no-pressure approach—ideal for those who want to bundle home and auto coverage on Stage Road.
- Shelter Insurance - David Johnson — 2743 Bartlett Blvd, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. David Johnson’s Shelter Insurance office earned a 5.0-star rating from one review, but that single review mentions exceptional customer service on a complex claim. Situated on busy Bartlett Boulevard, this agency is worth a visit if you want a local Shelter representative.
- Direct Auto Insurance — 6840 Stage Rd, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Direct Auto Insurance is a powerhouse with a 4.9-star rating from 571 reviews, making it one of the most-reviewed agencies in town. Located on Stage Road, they’re especially popular for budget-friendly auto policies and quick, in-person quotes.
- Jeff Herman - State Farm Insurance Agent — 3205 Kirby Whitten Rd Suite 101, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Jeff Herman has a stellar 4.9-star rating from 416 reviews, reflecting his long-standing reputation near Kirby Whitten Road. Customers appreciate his proactive check-ins and thorough coverage reviews, especially for families with multiple vehicles.
- Acceptance Insurance — 3445 Austin Peay Hwy, Memphis, TN 38128, USA. Although technically just outside Bartlett on Austin Peay Highway in Memphis, Acceptance Insurance serves many Bartlett residents and holds a 4.9-star rating from 401 reviews. They specialize in high-risk auto insurance and SR-22 filings, making them a reliable option for drivers who need flexible payment plans.
- Michele Agnew - State Farm Insurance Agent — 6600 Stage Rd #142, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Michele Agnew’s Stage Road office boasts a 4.9-star rating from 215 reviews. Regulars mention her friendly team and straightforward advice, which is especially helpful for first-time homebuyers navigating Bartlett’s real estate market.
- McDonald Insurance & Financial Services — 5820 Stage Rd, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. McDonald Insurance & Financial Services holds a 4.9-star rating from 92 reviews and is known for offering both insurance and retirement planning. Located on Stage Road, they’re a solid pick for locals who want to coordinate their insurance with long-term financial goals.
- Trey Clemens - State Farm Insurance Agent — 2919 Elmore Park Rd Suite 3, Bartlett, TN 38134, USA. Trey Clemens rounds out the list with a 4.9-star rating from 77 reviews. Situated near Elmore Park, his agency is praised for quick response times and a genuine interest in helping Bartlett residents save on bundled policies.
When you’re ready to shop for insurance in Bartlett, the best time to compare quotes is a few weeks before your current policy expires—this gives you room to ask questions without rushing. A few smart questions to ask any agent: “How do you handle claims after a severe storm?” and “What discounts do you offer for bundling home and auto?” In Bartlett, a fair price for a standard auto policy usually falls between $100 and $150 per month, depending on your driving record and coverage limits, so don’t hesitate to get at least three quotes from the agencies above.