Choosing the right insurance agent in Dublin can make all the difference when you need personalized guidance for your home, auto, or life coverage—whether you’re a long-time resident or new to the Bridge Street corridor. Locals should look for an agent who understands the unique risks and needs of central Ohio, from severe weather to growing suburban traffic, and who takes the time to explain policies clearly. With that in mind, here are the top-rated insurance agents in Dublin, all earning a perfect 5.0-star rating from their customers, based on verified reviews collected through September 2026.
1. Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc — 4266 Tuller Rd, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (196 reviews) Serving the broader Dublin community from their Tuller Road office, this agency is the most-reviewed perfect 5.0-star option in the area, with nearly 200 customers giving them top marks. Their strong local reputation suggests a deep commitment to client education and advocacy, making them a reliable first call for residents comparing policies.
2. Meridian Insurance Inc. — 6055 Tain Dr Suite 107 G, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (102 reviews) With over a hundred glowing reviews and a pristine 5.0-star rating, Meridian Insurance stands out for its convenient location near the Tain Drive office complex and its consistent ability to earn customer trust. Whether you need auto, home, or business coverage, their personalized approach keeps Dublin families coming back.
3. Adam Deel - State Farm Insurance Agent — 6235 Emerald Pkwy, Dublin, OH 43016, USA | 5.0 stars (71 reviews) A familiar face for State Farm customers in the Emerald Parkway area, Adam Deel has built a loyal following with 71 perfect reviews. As a local agent with a national brand, he combines trusted resources with the kind of neighborhood service that helps Dubliners feel confident in their coverage.
4. Griffin-Lantz Insurance Agency — 6047 Frantz Rd #206, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (66 reviews) Located just off Frantz Road near the heart of Dublin, this agency has earned a flawless 5.0-star rating from 66 reviewers. Griffin-Lantz is known for its independent agency model, which allows them to shop multiple carriers to find the right fit for each client’s unique situation.
5. The Keenan Agency — 6805 Avery-Muirfield Dr STE 200, Dublin, OH 43016, USA | 5.0 stars (35 reviews) Serving the Avery-Muirfield neighborhood and beyond, The Keenan Agency boasts a perfect score from 35 reviews. Their strong local ties and focus on both personal and commercial lines make them a go-to for Dublin small business owners and homeowners alike.
6. John Ren Insurance Agency — 6457 Reflections Dr #270, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (24 reviews) With 24 perfect reviews, John Ren Insurance Agency offers a boutique experience from their Reflections Drive office. They’re especially appreciated by clients who value clear explanations and a straightforward claims process—a big plus when you’re navigating coverage for the first time.
7. Farmers Insurance - Samantha Reffitt — 6245 Emerald Pkwy Ste C, Dublin, OH 43016, USA | 5.0 stars (17 reviews) Samantha Reffitt’s Farmers Insurance office on Emerald Parkway has earned a perfect 5.0-star rating from its first 17 reviews. As a newer agency in Dublin, she brings fresh energy and a national carrier’s resources, making her a strong choice for auto and renters policies.
8. Goosehead Insurance - Julie Light — 5650 Blazer Pkwy Suite 143, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (15 reviews) Julie Light at Goosehead Insurance operates from the Blazer Parkway business corridor, offering an independent brokerage model that lets you compare quotes from top carriers. Her perfect rating from 15 reviews signals exceptional client service for Dublin residents seeking flexible, tailored options.
9. McCaffrey Insurance Agency — 5114 Blazer Pkwy, Dublin, OH 43017, USA | 5.0 stars (9 reviews) Though newer to the ratings scene with just 9 reviews, McCaffrey Insurance Agency has already achieved a perfect 5.0-star score. Located on Blazer Parkway, this agency focuses on building long-term relationships and is a great option for anyone looking for a smaller, hands-on partner.
10. Nationwide Insurance: Nolan Insurance Agency Inc. — 6365 Shier Rings Rd, Dublin, OH 43016, USA | 5.0 stars (4 reviews) With a fresh 5.0-star rating from its initial 4 reviews, Nolan Insurance Agency on Shier Rings Road is a promising local Nationwide affiliate. Their early reviews highlight attentive service and a straightforward quoting process—perfect for Dublin residents who prefer a well-known brand with a local face.
When you’re ready to pick an agent, keep a few local tips in mind. The best time to shop for insurance in Dublin is during late summer or early fall, when many carriers run seasonal discounts and before the winter weather risks ramp up. Always ask potential agents about bundling options for home and auto, and request a detailed explanation of how your deductible works in Ohio’s storm-prone climate. For a fair price in central Ohio, expect to pay roughly $900–$