Choosing a great insurance agent in Fishers matters because your home, car, and family deserve coverage that’s as reliable as the community itself. With so many options in this growing city, locals should look for agents who combine personalized service with strong local knowledge and consistently high ratings from neighbors. The following ten agents have earned top marks from Fishers residents, making them standouts for anyone shopping for insurance in 2026.
- DeWitt Insurance Group — 8100 E 106th St Suite 260, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | With a perfect 5.0-star rating from 230 reviews, DeWitt Insurance Group is a clear favorite among Fishers families and business owners. Located near the heart of the city, they’re known for taking the time to explain coverage options clearly, whether you need auto, home, or commercial policies. Their long list of satisfied customers speaks to a team that genuinely cares about protecting what matters most.
- Priority Risk Management Inc. — 7050 E 116th St #200, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | Earning a flawless 5.0 stars from 197 reviews, Priority Risk Management is a go-to for those who want a no-nonsense approach to insurance. They serve clients across Fishers and the surrounding area, with a reputation for finding competitive rates without sacrificing coverage. Many reviewers appreciate their responsive support and willingness to answer questions after the policy is signed.
- Ray Insurance Group — 11411 Overlook Dr, Fishers, IN 46037, USA | Ray Insurance Group holds a strong 5.0-star rating from 144 reviews, making them a trusted choice for residents on the northeast side of Fishers. They specialize in bundling home and auto policies to save clients money, and their office is known for a friendly, small-business feel. Customers often mention how agents go the extra mile during claims, which is exactly what you want in a stressful situation.
- Source Insurance Group — 8388 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | With a perfect 5.0-star rating from 31 reviews, Source Insurance Group may be smaller but packs a punch in personalized service. Located on busy 116th Street, they offer a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products. Early clients rave about the attentive, consultative approach—ideal for first-time buyers or anyone switching providers.
- First Priority Insurance — 9742 Olympia Dr, Fishers, IN 46037, USA | First Priority Insurance boasts a 5.0-star rating from 21 reviews, proving that even a newer agency can earn quick trust. Situated near the Geist area, they focus on helping families and individuals find affordable coverage without cutting corners. Reviewers highlight the straightforward quotes and the team’s patience in explaining policy details.
- The George Insurance Agency — 12574 Promise Creek Ln, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | This agency carries a perfect 5.0-star rating from 10 reviews, and while the sample is small, every single customer has given top marks. Located in a quiet residential pocket of Fishers, they offer a personal touch that larger chains sometimes miss. If you value a one-on-one relationship with your agent, The George Insurance Agency is worth a call.
- Beau Mabrey Agency LLC American Family Insurance — 11650 Lantern Rd Unit 104, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | With a 5.0-star rating from just 2 reviews so far, Beau Mabrey Agency is a fresh face in Fishers—but those early reviews are glowing. As an American Family Insurance agent, they can bundle home, auto, and life policies with a well-known national carrier. Locals looking for a new agent with a modern, approachable style should stop by the Lantern Road office.
- Brandon Libunao - State Farm Insurance Agent — 8594 E 116th St # 20, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | Brandon Libunao has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from 463 reviews, making him one of the most-reviewed agents in Fishers. His office near the intersection of 116th and Olio serves a huge number of local households, and customers consistently praise his team for fast claim handling and clear communication. If you want an agent with a proven track record and a massive base of happy clients, this is a top contender.
- Clint Wilson - State Farm Insurance Agent — 13577 126th St, Fishers, IN 46037, USA | Clint Wilson holds a 4.9-star rating from 315 reviews, a testament to his dedication to the Fishers community. Located on 126th Street, his agency is especially popular with families in the newer subdivisions. Reviewers often note that Clint and his staff make insurance feel simple—they break down coverage options without pushing unnecessary add-ons.
- Amy Henry - State Farm Insurance Agent — 7319 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46038, USA | Amy Henry rounds out the list with a 4.9-star rating from 234 reviews, another State Farm agent who knows Fishers well. Her office on 116th Street is convenient for residents on the west side of town, and clients frequently mention her friendly, down-to-earth demeanor. Whether you need renters insurance or a full home-and-auto bundle, Amy’s team is known for finding the right fit.
When you’re shopping for insurance in Fishers, timing and preparation matter. The best time to compare agents is a few weeks before your current policy renews—this gives you room to ask questions and switch without a coverage gap. Always ask each agent how they handle claims locally: do they have a dedicated adjuster, or will you be routed to a national call center? As for fair pricing, a bundled home and auto policy in Fishers typically runs between $1,200 and $1,800 per year for a standard home and two vehicles, though rates vary widely by risk factors. Take advantage of the free quotes these top-rated agents offer, and trust the reviews from your neighbors—they’ve already done the homework.