RatingsNearMeSee All Insurance Agents in New Braunfels
Insurance AgentsNew Braunfels, TX

Top 10 Insurance Agents in New Braunfels, TX — May 2026

Looking for the best insurance agents in New Braunfels, TX? We ranked the top 10 local options by real customer ratings for May 2026.

Published May 24, 2026

Choosing the right insurance agent in New Braunfels can make a significant difference in your coverage, costs, and overall experience. As a local resident, you want to work with an agent who truly understands the unique needs and challenges of our community. Fortunately, New Braunfels is home to a wealth of top-rated insurance professionals who are dedicated to providing exceptional service.

  1. Medicare Gals Legacy Group - With a perfect 5.0-star rating from over 245 customers, the Medicare Gals Legacy Group is a trusted choice for New Braunfels residents seeking expert guidance on Medicare and other insurance solutions. Conveniently located at 2090 I-35 Suite 4105, this agency specializes in helping seniors navigate the complexities of Medicare and find the right coverage to meet their needs.
  1. Farmers Insurance - Josh Blanchett - As a local Farmers Insurance agent, Josh Blanchett has earned a flawless 5.0-star rating from 118 reviews. Serving the New Braunfels community from his office at 1110 W San Antonio St, Blanchett is known for his personalized approach, extensive industry knowledge, and commitment to finding the best insurance products for his clients.
  1. Coverall Insurance Agency - Situated at 4510 FM 1102, Coverall Insurance Agency has built a reputation for excellence, earning a perfect 5.0-star rating from 95 customers. This agency specializes in a wide range of insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, and business coverage, ensuring that New Braunfels residents have access to comprehensive protection.
  1. Primero Insurance - With a 5.0-star rating from 88 reviews, Primero Insurance at 388 Landa St is a top choice for New Braunfels residents seeking a reliable and knowledgeable insurance partner. This agency excels at providing personalized attention and customized insurance plans to meet the unique needs of each client.
  1. Brenda Heulitt Insurance Agency - Located at 1111 N Walnut Ave #102, the Brenda Heulitt Insurance Agency has earned a perfect 5.0-star rating from 63 customers. Brenda and her team are known for their exceptional customer service, deep understanding of the local insurance landscape, and their ability to find the most suitable coverage options for New Braunfels residents.
  1. Gruene Insurance Group - Situated in the heart of the historic Gruene district at 1198 Gruene Rd C, the Gruene Insurance Group has a flawless 5.0-star rating from 60 reviews. This agency specializes in providing personalized insurance solutions for New Braunfels families and businesses, with a focus on building long-term relationships with their clients.
  1. Lieck Insurance Agency - At 3702 S I-35 South Frontage Rd #109, the Lieck Insurance Agency has earned a 5.0-star rating from 26 customers. This agency is known for its expertise in a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, life, and commercial coverage, making it a one-stop-shop for New Braunfels residents.
  1. Jordan Pitts at Comparion Insurance Agency - Located at 111 W San Antonio St #250, Jordan Pitts at Comparion Insurance Agency has a perfect 5.0-star rating from 13 reviews. Pitts is known for his personalized approach, exceptional customer service, and his ability to help New Braunfels residents find the most suitable insurance solutions for their needs.
  1. Carlos M. Garcia- New York Life Insurance Agent - Based at 910 Gruene Rd, Carlos M. Garcia is a New York Life Insurance agent who has earned a 5.0-star rating from 4 customers. Garcia is known for his expertise in life insurance and his dedication to helping New Braunfels residents protect their families and financial futures.
  1. HealthMarkets Insurance - Kristin Cloud - Situated at 2090 Sundance Parkway #5108, HealthMarkets Insurance - Kristin Cloud has a 5.0-star rating from 2 reviews. Cloud specializes in providing health insurance solutions, including Medicare and individual/family plans, ensuring that New Braunfels residents have access to the coverage they need.

When it comes to finding the right insurance agent in New Braunfels, the best time to start your search is before you need coverage. Take the time to research local agencies, read reviews, and schedule consultations to find the agent who best understands your unique needs and offers competitive rates. Remember, a fair price for insurance services in the New Braunfels area can vary depending on the coverage, but you should expect to pay a fair market rate that aligns with your budget and provides the protection you require.

Ready to find a Insurance Agent in New Braunfels?

Browse verified ratings, read reviews, and get a free quote from the top-rated local pros.

View Top Insurance Agents in New Braunfels
← Browse all local guides